2018 Marie Curie Individual Fellowship (H2020-MSCA-IF-2018)

[ATBGF2017]

This is my second year and last year I was above the threshold. This year I addressed the "weaknesses" so conventional wisdom tells me that my point should go up, whether I pass the funding threshold or not. That being said, I have heard many stories where people saw their points decrease the second time. Anything is possible I guess!

Last year i stayed in EVALUATION until the end and I could not pass the threshold.

[Flocci]

Logically it should be as you say. So, are you on evaluation or ranking now?


quote=ATBGF2017 post_id=3454 time=1548778375 user_id=111]
This is my second year and last year I was above the threshold. This year I addressed the "weaknesses" so conventional wisdom tells me that my point should go up, whether I pass the funding threshold or not. That being said, I have heard many stories where people saw their points decrease the second time. Anything is possible I guess!

Last year i stayed in EVALUATION until the end and I could not pass the threshold.

[/quote]

[megasphaera]

That's something that puzzles me. They have the evaluations from previous year right?

This is my second year and last year I was above the threshold. This year I addressed the "weaknesses" so conventional wisdom tells me that my point should go up, whether I pass the funding threshold or not. That being said, I have heard many stories where people saw their points decrease the second time. Anything is possible I guess!

Last year i stayed in EVALUATION until the end and I could not pass the threshold.

[ATBGF2017]

Evaluation...

Logically it should be as you say. So, are you on evaluation or ranking now?


quote=ATBGF2017 post_id=3454 time=1548778375 user_id=111]
This is my second year and last year I was above the threshold. This year I addressed the "weaknesses" so conventional wisdom tells me that my point should go up, whether I pass the funding threshold or not. That being said, I have heard many stories where people saw their points decrease the second time. Anything is possible I guess!

Last year i stayed in EVALUATION until the end and I could not pass the threshold.

[/quote]

[ATBGF2017]

I think they know that it is a resubmission. And, if I am not mistaken, they get to see previous year's evals once they upload theirs...

That's something that puzzles me. They have the evaluations from previous year right?

This is my second year and last year I was above the threshold. This year I addressed the "weaknesses" so conventional wisdom tells me that my point should go up, whether I pass the funding threshold or not. That being said, I have heard many stories where people saw their points decrease the second time. Anything is possible I guess!

Last year i stayed in EVALUATION until the end and I could not pass the threshold.

[megasphaera]

Ok, so they do not see any previous evaluations before writing their reports.

I think they know that it is a resubmission. And, if I am not mistaken, they get to see previous year's evals once they upload theirs...

That's something that puzzles me. They have the evaluations from previous year right?

This is my second year and last year I was above the threshold. This year I addressed the "weaknesses" so conventional wisdom tells me that my point should go up, whether I pass the funding threshold or not. That being said, I have heard many stories where people saw their points decrease the second time. Anything is possible I guess!

[Flocci]

Than I assume there should be another round of ranking before launch of results.



uote=ATBGF2017 post_id=3457 time=1548778815 user_id=111]
Evaluation...

Logically it should be as you say. So, are you on evaluation or ranking now?


quote=ATBGF2017 post_id=3454 time=1548778375 user_id=111]
This is my second year and last year I was above the threshold. This year I addressed the "weaknesses" so conventional wisdom tells me that my point should go up, whether I pass the funding threshold or not. That being said, I have heard many stories where people saw their points decrease the second time. Anything is possible I guess!

Last year i stayed in EVALUATION until the end and I could not pass the threshold.

[/quote]
[/quote]

[xman25]

I really can't sleep tonight (now is 00:27 am) in Asia.

[fr489]

845*** SOC, I'm in Ranking (but I just checked, so I cant' say when it changed)

[sound]

They have the previous years evaluation during the consensus report. Not when the reviewers make the individual report.

Ok, so they do not see any previous evaluations before writing their reports.

I think they know that it is a resubmission. And, if I am not mistaken, they get to see previous year's evals once they upload theirs...

That's something that puzzles me. They have the evaluations from previous year right?