2017 Marie Curie Individual Fellowship (H2020-MSCA-IF-2017)

[dsmg]

email came at 2:59 am (GMT), IF-ST ENV panel proposal ID 79XXXX

79 and what digit after it?

Amar, did you get results?

[Amar]

No luck here as well...
Proposal Id 798XXX rejected for the second time...

Good luck to you all!

BTW, can anyone access the FO?

Thank you for the update. Goodl luck to you too.
When did you receive the mail?

[Satrius]

I am among the rejected!

It is frustrating and demotivating to see that your application has been evaluated by people who are totally incompetent for your subject, and who have decided to reject even though they can not deny the quality of the project.
For those working in Humanities these opportunities of funding are very rare, and greater impartiality and competence should be guaranteed.

Second rejection this year. GF-SOC 83%. Reviews were of much higher quality this year, and written in such a way that it is clear how to address them - last year I got a couple of general comments like "insufficient detail"/"insufficient information" that are not helpful for improving a proposal. However I am sure the reviewers will find new weaknesses next year. I am still very disappointed but nothing can be changed now!

In my case review quality is very bad. I can't imagine how some one can give such non serious comments. I am ok I had alternative options but there are people who really need this and reviewer show such non serious attitude.

Everybody gets some review comments of questionable quality (myself included). This is how MSCA works... If you intend to re-apply you should keep this in mind (to not get frustrated )!!!

In my publication plan, I had the top venues (both conferences and journals) of my domain and I got this comment: "the respective venues are of medium quality". At best, this reviewer is not very familiar with the domain so I wonder why he/she reviewed my proposal.
Not complaining, I knew that it is always possible to get such comments with MSCA...

[Amar]

email came at 2:59 am (GMT), IF-ST ENV panel proposal ID 79XXXX

79 and what digit after it?

Amar, did you get results?

No.
ST -LIF.
ID 799xxxxxxx.
Waiting...

[Satrius]

as a statistic, ID 7948** and I received the email around 5:30 am

[dsmg]

79 and what digit after it?

Amar, did you get results?

No.
ST -LIF.
ID 799xxxxxxx.
Waiting...

Any guess? when can we expect the results? I am 8000XX.

[Nick_F]

No luck here as well...
Proposal Id 798XXX rejected for the second time...

Good luck to you all!

BTW, can anyone access the FO?

Thank you for the update. Goodl luck to you too.
When did you receive the mail?

10:35 A.M. UK time

[fun4sci]

I've just received invitation to prepare grant agreement!
11:52h CET. Msca-if-ef-se. area phy.
Ranking since last week. ID 79*****

Sorry, 79 and what is next number - i have 799xxx - just want know where it stands....

798***

[all_Al]

799***

... and still nothing
..maybe under threshold.....

[Ani]

No luck here as well...
Proposal Id 798XXX rejected for the second time...

Good luck to you all!

BTW, can anyone access the FO?

Thank you for the update. Goodl luck to you too.
When did you receive the mail?

10:35 A.M. UK time

Got it----(rejection)
Proposal ID: 798xxx
Message received at 12:09
Conclusion so far: If your status was RANKING before 18th, then there are almost no chances.