2023 Reserve list (HE-MSCA-PF-2023)

[ella_]

94.4 ENV-EF, I also saw a 95 and 94.6 mentioned on this forum also on reserve list, so even with such high scores probably still plenty waiting before me! I was so stupid to open the evaluation before the letter considering previous years it seemed to me quite a good chance to be funded!

I got 95% in EF-ENV and am on the reserve list, but my proposal is with a UK host, so I think you stand a better chance of getting it than me. The situation is not entirely clear on what will happen to the reserve list for UK proposals, but I don't think we stand much of a chance of getting funding.

95% and not over the cut-off ; imagine how small the difference is with a proposal that just made it over the cut-off. I have my fingers crossed for you that they just keep the same reserve list in the UK!

[Hostos]

Does anyone know where the proposals ranking will be published?

[balinth11]

Hi everyone! I am currently on the reserve list with 92.8 score (EF-CHE) One friend of mine in the same category got the scholarship with 93.4 score, so the cut-off score should be somewhere between these two numbers.

[Madapura]

I got a 92.8%, EF-Spain, ENV and on reserve list. Gradually loosing the hopes that I had yesterday as I read the comments here!
one of the weakness under excellence was lack of significant publications in the last 3 years. I was under the impression that the CV strength was not evaluated!

[gincidentallyinquiry]

I got a 92.8%, EF-Spain, ENV and on reserve list. Gradually loosing the hopes that I had yesterday as I read the comments here!
one of the weakness under excellence was lack of significant publications in the last 3 years. I was under the impression that the CV strength was not evaluated!

If I am not mistaken, your CV is evaluated in relation to your proposal. For instance, publications in a similar topic to your proposal, etc. I also think they evaluate your CV according to your career stage. I am a somewhat newly postdoc and do not have a lot of publications, but they mentioned my CV as a strength.

[gincidentallyinquiry]

Does anyone know where the proposals ranking will be published?

Do you mean the cutoff marks? If yes, very likely today.

[gincidentallyinquiry]

Hi and congrats to everyone here! I got 93.6 in EF SOC and am on the reserve list. Good luck everyone!

Hi! I am also on the EF SOC reserve list. If you get any information about the list via NCPs or any other source, could you please share? I will also make sure to post here anything I find out.

[gincidentallyinquiry]

Hello! Mine is 92.8, EF-SOC in Norway. Definitely a score that I saw funded in Norway last year ...

I know!!! The marks these years are absolutely crazy. I am so disappointed about this.

I am also on the EF SOC reserve list. If you get any information about the list via NCPs or any other source, could you please share? I will also make sure to post here anything I find out.

[Madapura]

I got a 92.8%, EF-Spain, ENV and on reserve list. Gradually loosing the hopes that I had yesterday as I read the comments here!
one of the weakness under excellence was lack of significant publications in the last 3 years. I was under the impression that the CV strength was not evaluated!

If I am not mistaken, your CV is evaluated in relation to your proposal. For instance, publications in a similar topic to your proposal, etc. I also think they evaluate your CV according to your career stage. I am a somewhat newly postdoc and do not have a lot of publications, but they mentioned my CV as a strength.

Well, my proposal is partially a continuation of my PhD (2019 graduated) and I have strong publications in the same field from 2020 and 2021. Not there after.. My CV has been quoted as a strength. Just felt that the quoting poor <3 yr publication record as a weakness and cut 0.5 marks is not very fair.

[eleo2093]

Hi guys,

I have contacted the NPC and they still don't know the ranking, but these are the cut-offs for each field EF:

CHE 93
ECO 89
ENG 94
ENV 95,2
LIF 94,4
MAT 92,2
PHY 92,8
SOC 94,6

Hope this will be helpful.