Talk Academia

hello, how can we see the evaluation report? If I access Actions > Follow-up as the instructions say I don't see any document. thanks!

yuri1cz wrote: ↑

Tue Feb 04, 2020 9:42 am

Still waiting for the official results but so far no e-mail or change in the website.

Finally, I saw my evaluation report: 96.8 (LIF). Still no email yet. Somebody with a project number of 891*** received any email? Fingers crossed for all of us!

The ec.europa site has crashed.

Still no signs of results!!!!

AdinaBabesh wrote: ↑

Tue Feb 04, 2020 9:36 am

I also have an ethics clearance and I do take it as a good sign.
For last year's application I didn't have this.

MC2020CAR wrote: ↑

Tue Feb 04, 2020 9:34 am

AdinaBabesh wrote: ↑

Tue Feb 04, 2020 9:30 am

Did somebody from CAR receive the official notification?

Thanks!

Nope, but the ethics appraisal got uploaded and I take it as a good sign

This is what the guidelines say:



EDIT: BTW, still no Evaluation Report, but I also have an Ethics Summary Report. Fingers crossed!

90.4, ENG panel reserve list.

From the comments, I think really minor things screwed my application. Misplacement of text from one section to another, outdated standard reference... I am biting my elbows!

Last year I would have 60 people in front of me so no hope to get through. I am reserve list also in Widening, but I don't really know how it works. Do you know how to check your actual position on the reserve list? How does it work for the Widening? Should I contact my NCP or wait for some portal update?

Hi guys and gals,

I got the rejection email earlier this morning: 86,8%, panel LIF, 3,9/4,9/4,6.

The excellence part broke my neck. Evaluators said that the project is very original and highly innovative, but criticized that it's not clear if my proposed approach will work (well, that's why I would like to try it out!). Another negative point was that it is very similar to what I have done before. If it's so similar, why the high risk comment?

Anyway. I'm surprised by the 4,9 in the impact section, I absolutely loathed writing that part. Maybe this emotional setting is my writing sweet spot

Congratulations to all who won the grant! And condolences to all the others.

Btw, does anyone know good funding schemes for innovative, high-risk research?

Indeed, finger crossed, I have both: the ESR and the EthSR. But it seems that currently the portal is experiencing some technical issues ...

cdemente wrote: ↑

Tue Feb 04, 2020 10:03 am

AdinaBabesh wrote: ↑

Tue Feb 04, 2020 9:36 am

I also have an ethics clearance and I do take it as a good sign.
For last year's application I didn't have this.

MC2020CAR wrote: ↑

Tue Feb 04, 2020 9:34 am

Nope, but the ethics appraisal got uploaded and I take it as a good sign

This is what the guidelines say:



EDIT: BTW, still no Evaluation Report, but I also have an Ethics Summary Report. Fingers crossed!

There are issues with accessing and uploading of documents in the Grant Management Services.

I hope it will not be all day

oreoreo wrote: ↑

Tue Feb 04, 2020 9:12 am

I think it is time to start a crowdfunding campaign for Dreamer

Why don't you start one

Rejection 87.8% so I was close!! Same old bullshit comments - no weaknesses on section 3 but scored 4.7!!! No big surprise but I am pleased for everyone that got it and wish everyone good luck