2018 Marie Curie Individual Fellowship (H2020-MSCA-IF-2018)

[Aman19]

I got my project reviewed by professionals (a company). They expect me getij 85+ at least based on their many funded projects but i got 72!

Same here, I also received professional support. This thing is just crazy. I can understand an incremental change. After all this is a very competitive fellowship. But a 14 point drop? That is total non-sense. These evaluators need to bring their shit together. I will also apply for re-evaluation...

In fact, It was global fellowship not one of those countries. Yes it was engineering. So You are suggesting not to request re-evaluation.

If your host is not from UK, germany or france, you dont stand a chance, especially in engineering

This was the second time. I do not care to be rejected. But I'm pissed off that getting same score. You know what also I got professional help to develop this year bid. yet nothing changed. Anyway, thank you for your support.

you should give it another go, since you have the proposal ready! wait and see what the ESR says.

[cukovic]

[Pratibha]

Moreover, one person in group have results of all applicants!

I really cannot believe that after all of this long waiting, it is ended like this, some people get "unofficial" result from NCP, while still there is no indication when the official result will be out.

I really cannot accept this

[danGFSOC]

I am very sorry for you!!! I am now very worried about my result, being in the same panel!

Same here, I also received professional support. This thing is just crazy. I can understand an incremental change. After all this is a very competitive fellowship. But a 14 point drop? That is total non-sense. These evaluators need to bring their shit together. I will also apply for re-evaluation...

In fact, It was global fellowship not one of those countries. Yes it was engineering. So You are suggesting not to request re-evaluation.

If your host is not from UK, germany or france, you dont stand a chance, especially in engineering

This was the second time. I do not care to be rejected. But I'm pissed off that getting same score. You know what also I got professional help to develop this year bid. yet nothing changed. Anyway, thank you for your support.

you should give it another go, since you have the proposal ready! wait and see what the ESR says.

[ATBGF2017]

So you are over the threshold? What was your phase?

I got my project reviewed by professionals (a company). They expect me getij 85+ at least based on their many funded projects but i got 72!

Same here, I also received professional support. This thing is just crazy. I can understand an incremental change. After all this is a very competitive fellowship. But a 14 point drop? That is total non-sense. These evaluators need to bring their shit together. I will also apply for re-evaluation...

In fact, It was global fellowship not one of those countries. Yes it was engineering. So You are suggesting not to request re-evaluation.




This was the second time. I do not care to be rejected. But I'm pissed off that getting same score. You know what also I got professional help to develop this year bid. yet nothing changed. Anyway, thank you for your support.

[MVS]

PM'd you - thanks in advance!

Hi, guys. All results are within NCPs, so please ask them or wait for official email. My NCP copied to me part of that list, but i have no for all.
Good luck!

They also have evaluation Summary Reports, and I got my. I see lot of strengths and a very few weaknesses. And I am not funded.

[ATBGF2017]

Thanks Dan. My fingers are crossed for you!

I am very sorry for you!!! I am now very worried about my result, being in the same panel!

Same here, I also received professional support. This thing is just crazy. I can understand an incremental change. After all this is a very competitive fellowship. But a 14 point drop? That is total non-sense. These evaluators need to bring their shit together. I will also apply for re-evaluation...

In fact, It was global fellowship not one of those countries. Yes it was engineering. So You are suggesting not to request re-evaluation.




This was the second time. I do not care to be rejected. But I'm pissed off that getting same score. You know what also I got professional help to develop this year bid. yet nothing changed. Anyway, thank you for your support.

[xman25]

So you are over the threshold? What was your phase?

I got my project reviewed by professionals (a company). They expect me getij 85+ at least based on their many funded projects but i got 72!

Same here, I also received professional support. This thing is just crazy. I can understand an incremental change. After all this is a very competitive fellowship. But a 14 point drop? That is total non-sense. These evaluators need to bring their shit together. I will also apply for re-evaluation...

I know my score from cukovic, I got only 6x......WHAT THE FUCK!

[gerdogan]

Exactly same. Last year I just gave it shot and the result increased my hope for this year. Exactly same as you I got 76 last year. and I spent whole summer this year and got 78. So did you get it yours at your 3rd attempt?

Don't be discouraged. When I tried the first time i drafted a project in 2 weeks and submitted. It was just a try to see and learn how it worked concretely without hoping too much. I got 77. The second time I worked full time spending my summer for 2 months. I got 77. However the quality of the comments were very different. There was more substance. Look at the comments more than at the score!

In fact, It was global fellowship not one of those countries. Yes it was engineering. So You are suggesting not to request re-evaluation.

If your host is not from UK, germany or france, you dont stand a chance, especially in engineering

This was the second time. I do not care to be rejected. But I'm pissed off that getting same score. You know what also I got professional help to develop this year bid. yet nothing changed. Anyway, thank you for your support.

you should give it another go, since you have the proposal ready! wait and see what the ESR says.

[Bren]

It's fukd up that someone on this forum has all of our results!!!!