Talk Academia

Well some people gave the ID and they received back info with the acronym and host, which they didn't disclose, so the list seems legit until now .. Has anyone been told by Dreamer they are getting it? Clearly there is a spreadsheet with project IDs to titles. But are we sure these are the *actual* ...

These are good and very good scores (according to the scoring grid from the guide for evaluators, google it). They are similar to the scores I have received last year, and I was on ranking. So, I would say that s/he was on ranking ;-) Shapovalol I do not do anything bad I just made typo mistake 3.9/...

If the EC assessed that you have addressed the ethics well enough then you shouldn't worry. Anyway, with such an important ethical section, if your project gets funded you could sit in front of an ethics committee at your host institution ... Hi guys, I am in RANKING but I have not been contacted by...

I don't get, did you receive a list with scores and evaluation reports ? Or you talk about last year ESR (if you applied of course).

Dreamer wrote: ↑

Mon Feb 03, 2020 11:21 am

My evaluation report is 3.9/4.5/4.1 and it is a really good comment.

If the NCP doesn't have confidentiality clauses to respect (and apparently s/he doesn't), then s/he won't get in any trouble ...

theresstillhope wrote: ↑

Mon Feb 03, 2020 10:47 am

Dreamer wrote: ↑

Mon Feb 03, 2020 10:38 am

I try to add a list but here xls extension is not supported. Sorry.

even if you have it, please do not share it. The NCP could get in trouble for this.

In the quide for evaluators it is mentioned that the EC meets with evaluators and vice-chairs ... Because I know an evaluator who will go to that meeting. I'm too shy to ask they if they'll evaluate MSCA or other calls :oops: if i would personally know a current evaluator of this call, i would ask t...

Final has everyone, it means that your application is final and not draft. Remember that you can submit as many versions of your application as you want. Before 11 September they are draft, after 11 September the last submitted one becomes final and it will be used for evaluation. Now, the infamous ...

Everyone can register as expert in the EC portal, but I don't think that all will be invited to perform evaluations. I think the Call administrators do a selection. It is true that the EC needs to rotate the experts up to a certain % every year (I don't remember it now, but I don't think is more tha...

We've been told the same during the MSCA workshop organised by the host institutions, that 40% successful application are actually resubmissions ... A while ago, I found some MSCA IF statistics (official document) and there they stated that resubmissions have a higher success rate on average than fi...

Here are some video briefings for MSCA -IF evaluators and evaluation process https://ec.europa.eu/info/h2020-msca-if-2018_fr It is interesting to watch. A drop of 20.2 points is super hurting... did you try to complain to the NCP or somewhere else for your 2018 application? Wish you will get it this...