Talk Academia

Can you try again next year? A colleague of mine went from a B (which reading the reviews seemed unjustified to me) to being funded next year by improving/ simplifying his proposal, without any change to the actual experiments in the proposal (I think he might have removed one experiment). I once d...

Hi all, do you think that it is possible to have two successful proposals in the same department (same panel) or are the panel members going to make a choice? For example in the case they are borderline with the score

chemeng wrote: ↑

Thu Jul 18, 2024 9:41 pm

1- 32 % = A and funded
33 - 55 % = A and not funded (may partly be in reserve list)
56 - 100 % = B and not funded

In my panel, 51% - 100% was B
36% funded

I would say try again anyway. Not all panels give much weight to the interview if the written proposal is good. Also, supposedly, if you don’t show for the interview they should, according to the official procedure, evaluate only what was submitted. So if what was submitted is very clear and very g...

Can you try again next year? A colleague of mine went from a B (which reading the reviews seemed unjustified to me) to being funded next year by improving/ simplifying his proposal, without any change to the actual experiments in the proposal (I think he might have removed one experiment). I once d...

Hey guys, do you have any information about the redress procedure? I got a B score despite many glowing reviews and only one critical review. Getting an "A not funded" would make the difference in dedicated national grants, do you think it is possible to challenge the score? I feel it's very unfair...

Hey guys, do you have any information about the redress procedure? I got a B score despite many glowing reviews and only one critical review. Getting an "A not funded" would make the difference in dedicated national grants, do you think it is possible to challenge the score? I feel it's very unfair ...

Evaluation, rejected with B, as I suspected

All outstanding reviews except for one, who challenged my project and profile in AI, although the project is about law. I guess I was unlucky

I am ranking, and I think I got the grant. I'm not in a good state to understand the results. The letter says clear congratulations and a score of A. However, the score A means "A (fully meets the ERC's excellence criterion and is recommended for funding if sufficient funds are available)". I am to...

ericrev wrote: ↑

Mon Jul 15, 2024 11:03 am

PE11
Funded, was in ranking.

Many congratulations! What was your experience in the interview? Did you feel positive?