Talk Academia

Given the vague summary report, has anyone asked for the full reviews of their proposal so that they may actually improve their application? It seems they should have these somewhere and they might actually be more illuminating than the cut-and-paste responses we received. Nope, these generic copy/...

Second rejection this year. GF-SOC 83%. Reviews were of much higher quality this year, and written in such a way that it is clear how to address them - last year I got a couple of general comments like "insufficient detail"/"insufficient information" that are not helpful for improving a proposal. H...

Ani wrote: ↑

Mon Jan 29, 2018 10:10 am

rsr wrote: ↑

Mon Jan 29, 2018 10:08 am

Got rejected.

Panel: ENG, ST
went to ranking on 12/01

Congrats to all the people who got it!!!

Sorry for that. Can you please write here the 1st three digits of your proposal ID?

Sure, 797XXX

Got rejected.

Panel: ENG, ST
went to ranking on 12/01

Congrats to all the people who got it!!!

Nothing yet for me... How am I supposed to sleep now?

Apparently there is no one left in Evaluation. I just wonder what it means for the proposals whose phase has changed today: 1. If it was similar to last year, it would mean that we scored very low; but they are aware that many people know the "links" (the Status field is hidden now) and they might ...

Akshath wrote: ↑

Wed Jan 24, 2018 2:50 pm

Mine also changed to ranking! Chemistry. I guess they saw our posts and decided to put ranking

Or are finalising all the lists to release the results in two days... Fingers crossed everyone!!!

Several people have great supervisors here or wrote their great proposal in a short period of time... But in a forum with many anxious researchers, I don't agree with bragging about such things... Let's just respect each other and try to go through this phase together instead of trying to show off. ...

Is it weird that I prefer to read about wrong assumptions over the links rather than hearing about the greatness of one's supervisor?? Hahaha, nope. PS. Also, my supervisor is SO much cooler than yours :lol: :lol: :lol: PPS. Sorry, this was too good to let it slide. Impossible!!!! Hahahaha We shoul...

Is it weird that I prefer to read about wrong assumptions over the links rather than hearing about the greatness of one's supervisor??